Escape Into Books
Your home for book news, reviews, and bookish fun. Follow along on Facebook.
In another universe, House Targaryen never rode dragons into Westerosi legend—they lit their enemies on fire with their minds.
George R.R. Martin revealed in a recent Oxford Union talk that, early on, he nearly gave the Targaryens a completely different power set: psychic fire abilities instead of flesh-and-blood dragons. The idea grew out of his science-fiction roots, long before A Song of Ice and Fire became synonymous with scaled weapons of mass destruction.
From science fiction ‘pyro people’ to real dragons
Martin explained that when he was first sketching out the world that would become Game of Thrones, he was torn over whether magic—and dragons—should exist at all. Coming off a career focused mostly on science fiction, he toyed with making the Targaryens a family of psionic “pyro people” who could ignite fires with their minds rather than command beasts from the sky. In his words, he’d already written successful stories about telepaths and empaths, and briefly considered giving Westeros the same kind of speculative twist.
The alternate Targaryen concept went far enough that it appeared in early drafts he shared with friend and fellow writer Phyllis Eisenstein. She pushed back hard, insisting that in a fantasy series the dragons needed to be real—not metaphors or extensions of psychic power. Martin has said before, including in a 2014 Rolling Stone interview, that Eisenstein’s advice convinced him to fully embrace the fantastical and put dragons on the page.
Looking back now, as HBO’s House of the Dragon and A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms keep expanding Targaryen history on screen, it’s hard to imagine Westeros without Drogon, Vhagar, or the dragon pit. Martin himself has said he can no longer picture the story without them.
Psychic echoes in today’s Targaryen stories
Traces of that scrapped “pyro people” era may linger in subtler Targaryen gifts. On television, both Helaena and Daemon Targaryen experience prophetic dreams in House of the Dragon, and HBO’s A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms also nods toward eerie foresight. They aren’t flinging fire with their thoughts, but the family’s connection to dreams and visions hints at a more psychic version of Targaryen power that might have been.
The revelation lands at a moment when Martin’s relationship to his own mythmaking is under a microscope. He’s juggling multiple Westeros projects—new seasons of House of the Dragon, the Dunk & Egg adaptation A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, and early work on an Aegon’s Conquest series—while side books like Fire & Blood and the Dunk & Egg novellas keep adding layers to Targaryen lore.
At the same time, readers are still fixated on the long wait for The Winds of Winter, which has now stretched well beyond a decade, as chronicled in timelines from outlets like The Week. We’ve covered how that delay ties into his growing slate of TV and side projects, from new spinoffs to teaching and events, in our look at Winds of Winter delays as GRRM juggles TV work.
What this alternate history says about Martin’s worldbuilding
Martin’s near-miss with psychic Targaryens underlines just how fluid Westeros once was. He has admitted he even considered stripping out magic entirely and writing the series as straight War of the Roses–style historical fiction before deciding to “make it more unexpected” by bringing in dragons and prophecy. That willingness to rethink fundamentals helps explain why his canon keeps evolving—through history tomes like Fire & Blood, through Dunk & Egg stories that now fuel a planned dozen new Dunk & Egg tales, and even through work beyond Westeros, such as co-authoring a recent physics paper tied to his long-running Wild Cards universe.
For fantasy readers, the “pyro people” reveal is a reminder that even the most iconic lore rests on precarious early choices. Change one conversation with a friend, and we might be arguing today about whether mind-fire Targaryens feel more “authentic” than dragon riders. Instead, dragons won—and reshaped modern epic fantasy along the way.
